How to participate in class without saying a word

academic advice class participation College High School
By Max S.

Does your grading rubric include a category like “classroom participation”? In my experience, when students learn they are being graded on their participation, their first reaction is to participate more: more frequently, more vigorously, more visibly. They raise their hand as often as possible, even before they’ve had time to really think through what they want to say. Some of the most “participatory” students will wave their hands in the air with great urgency, like they’re trying to guide a plane onto a runway during a storm. They think they’re demonstrating their A+ participation, but what I see is an unintentional distraction.

Participation in class is not about how many times you raise your hand or how often you contribute to class discussions. It is about the quality of your engagement in the classroom. In my classes, the students who are listening are often the most engaged. I look for the kids who have their notebooks out, their books open, their cell phones tucked away in their backpacks. Active listeners don’t only pay attention to their teacher, but also to their classmates. Their contributions to class discussions often build on their classmates’ ideas or respond to their classmates’ questions. In this way, they not only move the discussion forward but strengthen the sense that we are a class community whose members value and respect each other as thinkers and learners.

If you’re the type of student who always has their hand in the air, here are some tips to improve the quality of your engagement:

Put your hand down until others are done speaking. Take notes on what they say. Commit to a certain maximum number of comments per class, and make sure to keep count of how many times you contribute. Make each contribution count, by demonstrating not only your own thoughts but also your ability to listen and learn from others.

If you’re the type of student who rarely contributes, consider the following ideas:

Some students find it helpful to commit to one comment per class period. Some like to write out their comment (or at least bullet points) before raising their hand, to help them if their mind goes blank. If you’re not sure what to say, remember you can always respond to what your classmates are saying. For starters, sharing that you agree with a classmate’s point of view or appreciate one of their insights brings the class closer, demonstrates your listening skills, and helps you practice contributing to class in a low stakes way. Finally, if you’re worried about participation, schedule a time to speak with your teacher. Ask them for their guidance and support, and try to leave that meeting with at least one concrete suggestion for improving your participation.

It’s often said that we humans have one mouth and two ears, and that we should use them accordingly. While it may feel counterintuitive at first, it’s true in the classroom: the more you listen, the higher the quality of what you say. Keep that in mind each time you raise your hand.


academics study skills MCAT medical school admissions SAT expository writing college admissions English MD/PhD admissions GMAT GRE LSAT writing chemistry strategy physics math ACT biology graduate admissions language learning law school admissions test anxiety interview prep MBA admissions premed homework help AP exams creative writing MD academic advice career advice personal statements study schedules summer activities Common Application history philosophy test prep computer science organic chemistry secondary applications supplements economics PSAT admissions coaching grammar law statistics & probability psychology ESL SSAT covid-19 legal studies reading comprehension research 1L CARS logic games USMLE dental admissions mathematics Spanish calculus engineering parents Latin verbal reasoning DAT excel political science French Linguistics Tutoring Approaches academic integrity case coaching chinese DO MBA coursework PhD admissions Social Advocacy admissions advice biochemistry classics diversity statement genetics geometry kinematics medical school mental health mentorship quantitative reasoning skills time management AMCAS Anki IB exams ISEE MD/PhD programs algebra art history artificial intelligence astrophysics athletics business business skills careers data science internships letters of recommendation resume science social sciences software engineering study abroad tech industry trigonometry work and activities 2L 3L Academic Interest DMD EMT English literature FlexMed Fourier Series Greek Italian London MD vs PhD MMI Montessori Pythagorean Theorem Python STEM Sentence Correction Step 2 TMDSAS Zoom acids and bases algorithms amino acids analysis essay architecture argumentative writing brain teaser campus visits cantonese capacitors capital markets cell biology central limit theorem chemical engineering chess chromatography class participation climate change clinical experience cold emails community service constitutional law consulting cover letters curriculum dental school distance learning electricity and magnetism enrichment european history executive function finance first generation student fun facts functions gap year harmonics health policy history of medicine history of science hybrid vehicles induction information sessions institutional actions integrated reasoning intern international students investing investment banking lab reports logic mandarin chinese mba mechanical engineering medical physics meiosis mitosis music music theory neurology office hours operating systems organization pedagogy phrase structure rules plagiarism poetry pre-dental presentations proofs pseudocode psych/soc quantum mechanics resistors resonance school selection simple linear regression sociology software stem cells stereochemistry study spots synthesis teaching technical interviews transfer typology units virtual interviews writing circles