The origins of the Electoral College

AP exams history political science

Title_ How to Study Efficiently for Hours On End (With the Help of a Tomato)-Feb-02-2021-10-29-29-16-PMToday, we’re taking a step back to examine the history of the Electoral College. Why do we have it, what is the logic behind its design, and what does this mean for our understanding of political representation in the US? 

Why do we have the Electoral College?

Historians, politicians, and political scientists have debated the origins of the Electoral College since its founding. A common explanation for the fact that we don’t directly elect the President is that the Founders didn’t trust average voters to make wise decisions. They instead entrusted that job to electors chosen by each state’s legislature. As numerous commentators have written, the Framers did eschew the possibility of direct election quickly, but that is not to suggest that all framers opposed a national popular vote.

The role of slavery in the Electoral College

Many Framers, including Jefferson, supported a national popular vote...at least in theory. However, Southern delegates to the Pennsylvania Convention had a vested interest in opposing a popular vote; a significant portion of their populations were slaves who were prohibited from voting. These delegates knew that relying on a popular vote would significantly diminish their influence relative to Northern states, which had larger white voting populations.

The solution devised by Southern delegates was to rely on a method of indirect representation that factored in both white and black populations. Each state would be allotted a number of electors who would directly vote for the President, with the number of electors determined according to each state’s representation in Congress. The Framers had already agreed to a method of Congressional representation that relied on the Three-Fifths Compromise, which counted five enslaved people equal to three free white people in order to preserve Southern influence in Congress. Thus, when the issue of representation in the Electoral College arose, the Framers drew on rules designed to count slaves toward white Southerners’ political advantage while denying the enslaved any and all democratic rights.

An Anti-Democratic Legacy   

To date, most common narratives around the origins of the EC obscure the impact of slavery on the fundamental design of our nation’s representative institutions. Slaveholders’ concern about protecting their political influence in Congress was fundamental to the design of the EC. It perhaps should not be a surprise that critiques arise every election cycle focused on the clearly anti-democratic rules and consequences of the institution. Even today, though the Three-Fifths Compromise is long abolished, many argue that the rules of the EC continue to disadvantage black and brown voters in urban areas relative to white suburban and rural voters. These dynamics are complicated and require an understanding of the workings of the EC and our current partisan and racial geography. 

Check out my next post where I discuss how to understand the dynamics between race, urbanicity, and democratic representation through the Electoral College.

Gabrielle M. holds a PhD in Government and Social Policy and an MA in Government and Social Policy, both from Harvard University. Her tutoring specialities include History (high school, AP, and college levels), as well as Political Science & Government.

Contact us!

Check out related blog posts below!

Wait, what is the electoral college again??

A Beginner’s Guide to Analyzing Historical Documents

SAT & AP Tutoring Approaches with Eric

Comments

topicTopics
academics MCAT study skills SAT medical school admissions expository writing English college admissions GRE GMAT LSAT MD/PhD admissions chemistry math physics ACT biology writing language learning strategy law school admissions graduate admissions MBA admissions creative writing homework help MD test anxiety AP exams interview prep summer activities history philosophy career advice academic advice premed ESL economics grammar personal statements study schedules admissions coaching law statistics & probability PSAT computer science organic chemistry psychology SSAT covid-19 CARS legal studies logic games USMLE calculus parents reading comprehension 1L Latin Spanish dental admissions DAT engineering excel political science French Linguistics Tutoring Approaches research DO MBA coursework Social Advocacy case coaching chinese classics genetics kinematics skills verbal reasoning ISEE academic integrity algebra business business skills careers geometry medical school mental health social sciences trigonometry 2L 3L Anki FlexMed Fourier Series Greek IB exams Italian MD/PhD programs STEM Sentence Correction Zoom amino acids analysis essay architecture art history artificial intelligence astrophysics athletics biochemistry capital markets cell biology central limit theorem chemical engineering chromatography climate change curriculum data science dental school diversity statement finance first generation student functions gap year harmonics health policy history of medicine history of science information sessions integrated reasoning international students investing investment banking mba meiosis mitosis music music theory neurology phrase structure rules plagiarism presentations pseudocode secondary applications sociology software software engineering teaching tech industry transfer typology virtual interviews writing circles