The role of insurance and common threats in health insurance markets

academics College health policy
By Rajet

Growing up, the GEICO Gecko and Allstate’s Mayhem were frequent fixtures of TV nights with my family. “15 minutes could save you 15% or more on car insurance” and “You’re in good hands” were slogans I knew for as long as I could remember. Clearly, the services these companies were selling – different types of insurance – were marketed as taking care of consumers in a valuable way. Yet, for many individuals including myself, insurance was an ambiguous and poorly understood concept. In this blog post, I will demystify the basic role of insurance and discuss common threats to insurance markets (e.g., adverse selection and moral hazard).

The basic role of insurance

It is no secret that life can be unpredictable. At its core, insurance is a mechanism to reduce uncertainty, hedge against unpredictable losses, and pool risk. Insurance programs exist in countless domains – auto, home, life, etc. – but this post will illustrate key concepts of insurance markets by talking about health insurance in particular. Given our inherent urge to live long and healthy lives, mechanisms like insurance that mitigate the losses from unforeseen health events are powerful and in some cases life-saving.

Consider the example of Mr. A, a 50-year-old gentleman who, on a routine visit to a doctor, is found to have evidence of a condition for which diagnosis and treatment will cost him $100,000 over the next 3 months. With Mr. A’s $50,000/year-salary job and household of four to take care of, such an out-of-pocket expense would be catastrophic. Insurance markets seek to address this issue at the societal level by having individuals pay a lower, fixed cost with certainty to avoid a higher, potentially debilitating cost with uncertainty. More concretely, say a population of 1,000 individuals each pay $1,000 upfront (i.e., a fee known as a premium) for a health insurance plan; the insurer can then pool the $1,000,000 in premiums to offer benefits and cover services – either partially or in full – for individuals like Mr. A to alleviate uncertain financial hardship.

For insurance markets to operate efficiently in an economic sense, insurers offering insurance plans and individuals purchasing those plans would ideally have access to the same information. However, health care is a setting rife with information asymmetries. Individuals, for example, know more about their current and likely short-term future health status than insurers, while insurers may have access to more population-level data informing the services they choose to cover vs. not cover. In the sections that follow, I will talk about two potential threats to health insurance markets, both of which can arise from asymmetries in information. 

Adverse selection

Adverse selection in health insurance markets may occur as a result of individuals having more knowledge about their health status than insurers. Recall our friend Mr. A, who is now aware that he will incur at least $100,000 in medical expenses over the coming year. Now, imagine we have another patient, Ms. B, a healthy, 25-year-old young woman with no medical conditions and good health habits. Faced with a $1,000-premium health insurance plan, who would be quick to purchase the plan and who might be quicker to skirt it? Naturally, Mr. A would value the cost-savings, while Ms. B might view insurance as an unnecessary expense.

If such decisions were made by individuals at the population level, insurance plans would start to look less representative of the population as a whole and dominated by sicker, more medically expensive individuals. In response, to maintain their financial stability, insurance companies might raise their premiums. This may drive additional healthier individuals out of the plan, leading to spiraling costs and increasingly unaffordable prices. At some point, the entire insurance market will fail. A sustainable insurance market necessitates having individuals who are both low risk and high risk, with lower risk individuals paying into a system that helps alleviate burdens for those who are higher risk.

Moral hazard

Another type of information asymmetry can also occur in health insurance markets. Consider Mr. A again: what if Mr. A decides that in the presence of health insurance, he will more liberally seek health care services, since he will no longer bear the financial consequences of such a decision. In fact, it will help him to stay hyper-vigilant about his health going forward, he thinks. If there is information asymmetry such that an insurer does not anticipate this behavior, the insurance company will be at a relative disadvantage. All of a sudden, the insurer will have to pay a higher fraction of medical claims, driving an increase in premiums to maintain financial sustainability. To the extent that this issue is widespread and adverse selection is also at play, the health insurance market may eventually fail.

Conclusion

In sum, insurance can be an invaluable instrument to mitigate uncertainty and pool risk at a population level. However, threats to insurance plans like adverse selection and moral hazard must be anticipated and stemmed. In a subsequent post, I will dive into recent strategies that have emerged in the U.S. to mitigate such threats and ensure health insurance markets function more effectively.

Comments

topicTopics
academics study skills MCAT medical school admissions SAT college admissions expository writing English strategy MD/PhD admissions writing LSAT GMAT physics GRE chemistry biology math graduate admissions academic advice law school admissions ACT interview prep test anxiety language learning career advice premed MBA admissions personal statements homework help AP exams creative writing MD test prep study schedules computer science Common Application mathematics summer activities history philosophy secondary applications organic chemistry economics supplements research grammar 1L PSAT admissions coaching law psychology statistics & probability dental admissions legal studies ESL CARS PhD admissions SSAT covid-19 logic games reading comprehension calculus engineering USMLE mentorship Spanish parents Latin biochemistry case coaching verbal reasoning AMCAS DAT English literature STEM admissions advice excel medical school political science skills French Linguistics MBA coursework Tutoring Approaches academic integrity astrophysics chinese gap year genetics letters of recommendation mechanical engineering Anki DO Social Advocacy algebra art history artificial intelligence business careers cell biology classics data science dental school diversity statement geometry kinematics linear algebra mental health presentations quantitative reasoning study abroad tech industry technical interviews time management work and activities 2L DMD IB exams ISEE MD/PhD programs Sentence Correction adjusting to college algorithms amino acids analysis essay athletics business skills cold emails finance first generation student functions graphing information sessions international students internships logic networking poetry proofs resume revising science social sciences software engineering trigonometry units writer's block 3L AAMC Academic Interest EMT FlexMed Fourier Series Greek Health Professional Shortage Area Italian JD/MBA admissions Lagrange multipliers London MD vs PhD MMI Montessori National Health Service Corps Pythagorean Theorem Python Shakespeare Step 2 TMDSAS Taylor Series Truss Analysis Zoom acids and bases active learning architecture argumentative writing art art and design schools art portfolios bacteriology bibliographies biomedicine brain teaser campus visits cantonese capacitors capital markets central limit theorem centrifugal force chemical engineering chess chromatography class participation climate change clinical experience community service constitutional law consulting cover letters curriculum dementia demonstrated interest dimensional analysis distance learning econometrics electric engineering electricity and magnetism escape velocity evolution executive function fellowships freewriting genomics harmonics health policy history of medicine history of science hybrid vehicles hydrophobic effect ideal gas law immunology induction infinite institutional actions integrated reasoning intermolecular forces intern investing investment banking lab reports letter of continued interest linear maps mandarin chinese matrices mba medical physics meiosis microeconomics mitosis mnemonics music music theory nervous system